How is manure changing over time? Trends in Midwest manure sample data. By: Nancy Bohl Bormann the University of Minnesota

By
Jim
-
902

Key Points

  • Current livestock manure “book values” (the approximate amounts of various nutrients in manure) are several decades old.
  • Using recent data from several Midwest U.S. labs, we found that manure nutrient data have changed over time compared to previous Midwest Plan Service (MWPS) manure book values.
  • The University of Minnesota is creating a manure nutrient database called ManureDB to help update these values.
  • We are currently looking to partner with laboratories that analyze manure on this project.

What we did

Why do we care about manure? Manure is an organic fertilizer that contains essential plant nutrients. However, it can be a variable product, making it a challenge to match plant nutrient needs to the amount of nutrients in the manure. Like commercial fertilizers, we also need to be aware of the risk of losing nitrogen (N) and phosphorus (P) and affecting water quality.

What are manure nutrient “book values”? These nutrient averages are used for developing manure management plans, designing manure storages, creating best management practices for manure land application, and agricultural modeling. They show a range of nutrient values that can be expected from typical manure storages and encourage farmers to test their manure often. However, current book values are several decades old and may not reflect current production practices. Different animal diets, genetics, housing, and manure storage and handling practices can impact these manure nutrient values.

manure sampling

We are working with the Minnesota Supercomputing Institute to develop a manure nutrient database called ManureDB to create more accurate manure nutrient book values. In preparation for this project, we partnered with three Midwest U.S. laboratories to share data from approximately the last ten years. We compared those manure sample results to the estimated manure nutrient book values in Manure Characteristics published in 2004 by Midwest Plan Service (MWPS). We wanted to see if there were any nutrient trends and identify ways to make ManureDB useful and user-friendly.

We compared the nutrient averages of beef, dairy, poultry, and swine manure in both the liquid and solid forms. These are fairly generic comparisons as we did not have any details on animal housing, manure storages, or animal age. We converted the lab results and book values into pounds of nutrient per ton for solid manure and pounds of nutrient per 1,000 gallons of liquid manure. We used the median value for total nitrogen (N), ammonium-nitrogen (NH4-N), phosphorus (P2O5), and potassium (K2O) to look at the major nutrients needed for crop production.

What did we find?

Some of our results did differ from the MWPS published book values as shown in Tables 1 and 2 below. Without knowing swine age or manure storage systems, it was difficult to determine nutrient level changes for swine liquid manure. For liquid dairy manure samples, we found a decreasing trend over time for total N and P2O5 and an increasing trend in NH4-N. For liquid beef manure samples, we found an increasing trend for total N, NH4-N, and P2O5. For liquid poultry manure samples, we found an increasing trend for NH4-N and K2O and a decreasing trend for P2O5.

liquid manure sample trends graph

For solid swine, dairy, and beef manure samples, we found an increasing trend for total N, P2O5, and K2O. For solid poultry manure samples, we found an increasing trend for total N and K2O.

In the future, more details about the manure samples will make comparisons even more helpful. We know animal age, nutrition, housing, and manure storage and handling can impact manure nutrient levels.

liquid manure sample trends graph

What’s next?

ManureDB construction is underway and we are contacting laboratories and working on data-sharing agreements. We are primarily interested in the manure data and region that it comes from. ManureDB has mechanisms in place so that labs will not need to share customer-identifying information with us. We have our first few data agreements signed and are refining our manure data upload process and procedures.
If you are a lab interested in learning more about this project, please contact us! (Email manure@umn.edu.) We will compare data as we get access to it, especially for more detailed animal types.  As ManureDB evolves, we plan to have features available for public use. We are hoping to have the publicly available manure data dashboard released by the end of the year. This is tentatively based on when we get the first official set data from labs and how easily the data is standardized.

Additional information

Acknowledgments

This work is supported by the AFRI Foundational and Applied Science Program [grant no. 2020-67021-32465] from the USDA National Institute of Food and Agriculture, the University of Minnesota College of Food, Agricultural and Natural Resource Sciences, and the Minnesota Supercomputing Institute.
—

For the latest nutrient management information, subscribe to the Nutrient Management Podcast wherever you listen and never miss an episode! And don’t forget to subscribe to the Minnesota Crop News daily or weekly email newsletter, subscribe to our YouTube channel, like UMN Extension Nutrient Management on Facebook, follow us on Twitter, and visit our website.

RELATED ARTICLESMORE FROM AUTHOR